There are two seemingly diametrically opposed groups of people on the internet who could quite easily convince me that the entire world hates me.
One would have me believe that my very existence is an affront to women, that my presence in a ladies’ toilet is a source of enormous distress, and that I’m participating in some great misogynistic assault on women’s rights.
The other, whilst frequently motivated by an entirely understandable desire to protect people like me, could leave me with the impression that I inhabit an extraordinarily hostile world in which I ought to be permanently on my guard.
Both could probably do a reasonably convincing job of it, were it not for one rather inconvenient little detail.
I regularly leave the fucking house.
Now, before anybody misunderstands the premise of this essay, let me establish a few things.
I am not neutral when it comes to transgender rights. I have a rather considerable vested interest in them. I want transgender people to have access to the healthcare they need, to be treated with dignity, to have rewarding careers, friendships, relationships and fulfilling lives.
I’m also enormously grateful to many of the people who have campaigned, sometimes for decades, for the rights that I now enjoy.
But supporting a cause does not oblige me to endorse every argument made in its name.
And perhaps the reason I’m writing this is that I increasingly worry that some of the discourse surrounding transgender people, including some originating from within our own community, is making the pursuit of happiness considerably more difficult than it needs to be.
Confession Time
I sometimes read the Daily Telegraph.
Worse still, I have a subscription.
In my defence, it’s predominantly for the business section. I rather like Ambrose Evans-Pritchard and Jeremy Warner. They’re good journalists. And besides, I’ve managed to bargain the Telegraph down to such a ridiculously cheap subscription that it would almost be rude not to read it.
For my American readers, the Daily Telegraph is a fairly right-of-centre British newspaper. Although, given what constitutes right-of-centre in the United States these days, it’s probably positively liberal by comparison.
The problem is that, in getting to the business pages, I invariably have to wander through the front page.
And it is virtually impossible to get past the front page without encountering at least one article that goes something like:
Something something transgender something something madness something something they’re all crazy activists something something.
Christ almighty. I only wanted to know what was happening with the bond markets.
And I will tell you now, if I were to live my life believing that the reality of my existence was accurately reflected in the pages of the Daily Telegraph, I think I’d start to lose my fucking mind.
And that, ladies and gentlemen, is what I want to talk about today.
The real world versus the online world.
A Little Geographical Context
Before I go any further, I live in the Republic of Ireland, in County Cork. County Cork is populated by an awful lot of farmers and people who pronounce the word ‘cow’ in a manner that I can barely comprehend.
It is also a little bit woke, as is much of Ireland.
There. I’ve said it. It’s a bit woke.
In terms of providing me with the medical care I’ve needed as a transgender woman, Ireland has been practically useless. In terms of being supportive of my existence as a transgender woman, my experience has been overwhelmingly positive.
As I’ve said before, Ireland’s position seems to be:
You’re very welcome to be transgender. Now don’t be asking us for anything.
We even have self-ID for gender recognition certificates, which meant that obtaining my GRC was relatively painless when it came to declaring myself a woman, and extraordinarily painful when it came to establishing that I actually lived in Ireland.
Some of the palaver surrounding that was hilarious. At one point, my joint bank account wasn’t considered sufficient evidence of my residency because, theoretically, I could have been living in Switzerland whilst my ex-wife was spending all the money in Ireland.
And apparently I’d spent so much time in Thailand having surgery that, at one point, they were convinced I actually lived in Thailand.
Nobody seemed particularly concerned about my gender. My geographical location, however, was the subject of an international mystery.
We got there in the end with an old Revolut account.
But I digress.
I’m not living in Tanzania. I’m not living in Guatemala. I’m not living in Texas. I cannot speak for every transgender person in every corner of the world, and I’m not going to attempt to.
I can only speak about what I see, what I know, and what I’ve personally experienced.
Since transitioning, I’ve spent several months in Thailand. I’ve been to San Francisco, Canada, France, and, obviously, Ireland and the United Kingdom. Oh, and Turkey. I went and got myself chopped up in Turkey.
There are probably a couple of other countries I’ve forgotten about.
And I can only judge those places by how I’ve actually been treated in them, on a day-to-day basis, as a transgender woman going about her business.
With the exception of two encounters with airport staff, my experiences with strangers whilst out and about have been overwhelmingly positive.
Quite often, people have been absolutely delightful to me.
The Podcast Merry-Go-Round
And then there’s the enormous collection of podcasts on YouTube, where an apparently finite collection of guests goes round and round on a merry-go-round of each other’s shows, sitting there nodding like those little dogs people used to have on the parcel shelves of their cars.
All agreeing with one another about how dreadful everything to do with transgender people is.
There’s Andrew Gold on Heretics, who manages to look absolutely aghast every time somebody mentions cross-sex hormones, as though this is the very first time he’s heard about them.
There’s Peter Boghossian. There’s Jordan Peterson. There’s TRIGGERnometry. And, of course, there’s Helen Joyce of Sex Matters, a woman who seems particularly enamoured with the expression ‘trans-identified male’.
If Helen were to describe me as a trans-identified male and I asked her why she felt the need to use that particular expression, I suspect she’d tell me that it’s because it’s accurate and it’s the truth.
Well, Helen, I could turn around and say something like this:
”You are objectively, scientifically less attractive than the average woman. Shall I henceforth describe you as an unattractive woman? Why not, Helen? Surely I’m just being accurate and truthful?”
Now let’s see how you like it.
I can be fucking horrible if I want to be. But generally speaking, in civilised society, we look for the kinder ways to describe people.
There are multiple ways of expressing the truth. My contention is that Helen deliberately chooses the cruellest available description and then seeks to justify that choice on the grounds of accuracy.
I don’t think that’s a devotion to the truth.
I think it’s cruelty masquerading as intellectual honesty.
I’d absolutely love to debate that woman.
Anyway, throw in the enormous anti-trans accounts on X, the endless circulation of carefully selected video clips, and an algorithm that keeps serving you more of this stuff simply because you watched the last one, and you can create an entire little universe for yourself.
Spend enough time in that universe and you’d be forgiven for thinking that practically every woman in the country is terrified of encountering me in a ladies’ toilet, that I’m an extraordinarily misogynistic creature, and that the general population regards people like me with something approaching universal disgust.
If I took my cues about the world from all of this, I’d conclude that my life out there was an absolute shitshow.
It isn’t.
Meanwhile, Back in the Real World
The other day, I had an appointment regarding my Graves’ disease and found myself chatting to a doctor I’d never met before.
She was absolutely lovely. She was interested in me, interested in my transition, fascinated by some of the things I’d had done, and we chatted away quite happily.
And I will tell you now, that is fairly representative of my interactions with people in the real world.
I go to a bar. People are lovely to me.
I go into a shop and try on a dress. People are lovely to me.
I go out for dinner. I go to the hairdresser. I go and get my nails done.
I experience remarkably little friction attributable to my being transgender.
Now, I’m not stupid.
I know that I live in Ireland, and I also know that I’ve been extraordinarily fortunate in having had the financial means to undergo a considerable amount of surgery.
My forehead has been softened. My jaw has been softened. I’ve had a great deal of work done, and I don’t necessarily stand out particularly when I’m walking down the street.
Nobody really looks at me. Nobody stares.
About four months ago, I found myself walking behind another transgender woman who was rather more visibly transgender than I am.
And I watched people looking at her.
Not shouting at her. Not threatening her. Just looking at her in a way that people don’t generally look at me.
And I felt for her.
Because I thought, if you have to deal with that every single day of your life, psychologically, it must wear you down. The cumulative effect of constantly feeling that you’re being scrutinised must be considerable.
I’m conscious that I’ve effectively been able to purchase a degree of anonymity in the world that some other transgender women simply cannot afford.
And there is statistical evidence that my experience is not everybody’s experience. Ireland’s Central Statistics Office found in its 2024 survey that 46% of transgender and non-binary people had experienced some form of discrimination during the preceding two years, compared with 23% of cisgender people.
That is a significant disparity.
I don’t want to take my good fortune and use it as evidence that somebody else’s suffering isn’t real.
Equally, I don’t want somebody else’s suffering to persuade me that my own happiness isn’t real.
Both experiences exist. Both are valid. And I think there ought to be room for us to talk about both.
The Great British Toilet Crisis
And then, of course, we have toilets.
Christ almighty, the toilets.
We have somehow managed to turn the entirely mundane act of having a wee into one of the great political issues of our time.
I’m well aware of the Supreme Court judgment in the UK and the controversy surrounding single-sex facilities. I’m not particularly thrilled about any of it, and I’m aware that the consequences for some transgender people are very real.
But I’ve been to the UK on numerous occasions since the judgment.
I’ve used the ladies’ toilets on numerous occasions.
Do you know what has happened to me?
Nothing.
The most interaction I generally have with another woman in a ladies’ toilet is somebody asking me where I got my boots from, or telling me that she likes my eyeliner.
Nobody has screamed. Nobody has run out of the building. Nobody has confronted me.
Now, I cannot know what every woman in that toilet is thinking. I cannot tell you whether every one of them is entirely comfortable with my presence, or even whether they’ve realised I’m transgender.
And my personal experiences certainly don’t establish that the legal changes are inconsequential.
But what interests me is the sheer contrast between those quite ordinary, unremarkable human interactions and the extraordinary amount of hostility generated around the subject online.
There are millions of people out there who aren’t spending their evenings watching podcasts about transgender people. They aren’t arguing about sex and gender on Twitter. They aren’t reading the judgments of the Supreme Court.
They’re just getting on with their lives.
And I suspect an awful lot of them are rather less preoccupied with my existence than either I or the internet might imagine them to be.
Switch the Bloody Thing Off
So, if you’re transgender and you’re sitting at home feeling that the whole world is falling apart and everybody hates you, I’d like you to ask yourself a question.
How much of that feeling comes from what actually happens to you on a daily basis, and how much of it comes from what you’re consuming online?
Think about your last week. The people you’ve encountered, the conversations you’ve had, the places you’ve been. Think about the good experiences as well as the bad ones.
Is your real life anything like the online shitshow?
For some of you, the answer might be considerably less reassuring than it is for me. I appreciate that.
But the rather extraordinary thing about my life at this point is that, for considerable portions of my day, I completely forget that I’m transgender.
I’m just getting on with my bloody life.
I’m not suggesting we stop fighting discrimination. I’m suggesting that the fight for a better life shouldn’t consume so much of our energy that we forget to live the bloody thing.
I transitioned because I wanted to be happier, not because I wanted to become a permanent participant in a culture war.
And finally, I want to leave you with this.
Occasionally, I open up Instagram and am treated to the antics of two of my favourite transgender internet reprobates.
There’s Jessica Such, who has made something of a career out of accosting unsuspecting men in the street with her now familiar opening gambit:
Do you like blonde girls? Do you like transgender blonde girls?
And then there’s Stella Francis.
Just look at the pair of them. Strutting around Manchester, looking hot as fuck, laughing, flirting and generally having a thoroughly lovely time.
Do you honestly think either of these two is giving much of a stuff about what Andrew Gold, Jordan Peterson or Helen Joyce or Daily Telegraph has to say about them?
Whilst an entire industry has sprung up discussing the supposedly catastrophic implications of their existence, these two are rather inconveniently enjoying it.
And isn’t that ultimately what we’re fighting for?







This has absolutely been my experience as well. What I read online makes it sounds like they're hunting trans people for sport. When I go out, everything is completely normal. If anything, I have more pleasant interactions than I did before transitioning. I'm in New Mexico and pretty sure I look more visibly transgender than you, based on your photos.
Great read thank you
Yes, I agree with you to a large extent, as I'm in Canada and our society at large could give a fuck what I choose to call myself.
This doesn't mean I'm not aware of the 370+ transgender and non-binary people that have passed this year alone, in large part due to violence.
It means I can be aware, still have empathy and care, but I do have a life to live, and for the most part my life is doing well thank you very much
I was leading a much more tragic life as the man I pretended to be, so this is a great improvement
I'm not cute or physically attractive in a feminine way, and I don't care
I'm a 60+ year old witch enjoying my years, although it would be nice if someone could fix my knees LOL