17 Comments
User's avatar
Paula W's avatar

Jesus Stevie- Tears are flowing this end-Self acceptance for transgender individuals of our generation is one of the hardest bridges to cross- I am largely across that bridge but its a hard crossing!

Stevie Bennett's avatar

Largely across is further than a lot of us manage. And it isn't a bridge you cross once, is it.

Thank you for reading it. x

Paula W's avatar

I think true self acceptance of being trans is probably a one way one ticket crossing across the bridge. At least I hope so!? I've done many partial attempts.

Stevie Bennett's avatar

Fair. I'd rather have your version than mine.

And the partial attempts aren't failures, they're the practice runs. Nobody crosses it cold. x

JoAnne's avatar

Indeed our paths are different but, so many parallels, shame, guilt, hesitation, a life as was, and courage… yet something was missing.

The courage in leading a hidden life at best or in denial for xx years (in my case 65) consciously or subconsciously pretending to be something else, protecting that fragile self. Married, with a loving wife(now partner), a busy career, happy family life i have had it all, and yet 2+ years ago I realized… dysphoria clicked in big time.

And that word “courage” a word oft used to describe that step of becoming visible (me). When I heard people say this I used to think that that courage was not me. Now I realize that we have it, in spades!

And dysphoria…when it happened, i had no choice but to be me, whatever, to come out. Was it courage? That makes it sound like a choice… there was none.

A member of LGBTQ community, i have just become proud of, it’s taken a while. Lesbian i still struggle with a little bit, maybe thats a door opening…

Where I live i have just joined a group called “Fashionably Late” I like that phrase.

Was that north of England town steel town perchance?

You have a beautiful smile.

Stevie Bennett's avatar

"That makes it sound like a choice" is the truest line in your comment. People hand you courage like a medal, for something you did because the alternative had run out.

Sixty five years, and then no choice at all.

Fashionably Late is a very good name for it. I'll keep the town to myself, if you don't mind. And thank you. x

June Northey's avatar

Agreed on when the dysphoria hits a certain point there is no more choice. I hit that back in on January 28th at a local trans gathering - surrounded by trans women of all kinds - passing, not passing, old, young, middle aged. All happy with their lives. I knew I had to come out. No more hiding. The week+ I had to wait to have my daughters in the room to tell them (they are the most important thing in my life) was hell. Finally being out is heaven. I'm so happy, have so much going right it is insane. It is a dream. Guess life began at 56 1/2 for me.

Married...with consequences's avatar

This one brought me to tears because it sounds exactly like what my wife has explained to me. She used the term “self-loathing” but I think in many ways it was a form of shame. Her existence mirrors yours, you married at the same age, built a life, escaped into endurance sports, convinced yourself if you just did this next thing, achieved the next goal, built the perfect family life, the feeling would go away. It never did because this is who you are. And there is nothing to be ashamed of.

Stevie Bennett's avatar

Self-loathing is the more honest word. Shame at least implies an audience.

She's lucky you read it and recognised her in it. Not everyone gets that.

Imperfectly Broken and Bruised's avatar

I grew up feeling shame my entire life. Shame at having these "urges" to be a woman. Shame at giving in to those urges. Shame at trying to be a complete human being. And that shame very quickly became internalized into a self-loathing that has taken almost 50 years to begin to fade away, so yes, self-loathing was, for me, the appropriate term. I hated myself with a passion, and that self-hatred metastasized into something even bigger - I didn't care about how I looked, but I felt compelled to try to mold myself into as perfect a male physique as I could so that I would be unable to present as the female I always was inside of me, and that in turn served only to deepen that sense of self-loathing because at that point I felt that I did not have the courage or sense of self-preservation to be myself. Unlike Stevie, the urge or need to be my authentic self never went away. I never forgot it. It was always there in the background, but sometimes it was less intense than at other times, and there were some months where it was more just a wistful memory than an active need, but it always came roaring back at the most random of times, serving only to deepen the shame and self-loathing I felt.

But associated with the shame and self-loathing was guilt. And the guilt part was - and still is - about the deception that I visited upon those who I loved, and the one-time callous disregard I had for another girlfriend who did not deserve the runaround treatment that I gave her. When I met my wife and fell in love with her, all thoughts of self-actualization went out of the window, instead replaced by a fierce desire to be the person she thought I was, no matter the cost. So I disappeared into strength training, into my career, into cars, motorcycles, airplanes, bicycle riding and racing, gadgets, and any kind of other physical escapism that would distract me from the distress in my mind and body. I raced motorcycles, I flew airplanes in aerobatic competition, I beat myself up in physical endeavors so that I could numb the pain and distress of knowing what I was and the refusal to give into it.

And ultimately the cost would have been my life were I to have ignored the need to be myself for any longer. Because the feeling and need never went away; I was merely able to hold it at bay for a period of time.

When I finally admitted to myself that I was transgender, there was a palpable relief throughout my entire body. It was as if I had finally arrived at a conclusion, and that I could finally begin to see what the rest of my life would look like. When my wife discovered that I was transgender, the ensuing conversation was the most difficult one of my life - finally admitting publicly to the person I loved more than anyone or anything else in this world almost destroyed me, because it meant admitting to the decades of deception that I had enacted upon her and rendering her vision of the future into nothing, thus visiting so much emotional harm upon her that I questioned whether I should ever have tried to be with her.

But at the same time, that sense of shame started to leave me - that sense of shame at going into a store and, while presenting as a male, purchasing items that were for a female - clothes, makeup, wigs, nails, jewelry, shoes, and so on. That sense that society was judging me and finding me unworthy and unwholesome as a human being. However, it took substantially longer for the self-loathing to leave me, because for me the two were somewhat different - the shame was an externally-imposed worldview, whereas the self-loathing was about things I had done or not done in order to preserve the secrecy of my identity. It was about the deception and hurt that I caused my wife. It was also some level of internalized shame about being a freak, about being different, about "having" something that society deemed to be a disease but which was not, and was incurable, for it is impossible to "cure" being transgender; it is only possible to address it such that you can finally be yourself.

And that last little bit led me to the realization that the shame was very much attached to the notion of being mentally ill in a way that some factions of society deemed to be improper and that was viewed simply as a weakness of resolve that was akin to being a pedophile or some other such criminally deviant behavior, and once I understood that, the liberation of knowing that this was an utter fabrication of society allowed me to accept what I was and to give up this feeling of shame. Instead I am now proud of myself - proud that I have been able to embrace this life of mine, proud that I am finally able to no longer suppress that feeling, and proud that I am able to live as myself for the rest of my life.

The guilt, however, lives on, and that is something I am still working on.

Stevie Bennett's avatar

The guilt outlasting the shame is the part nobody says out loud. Shame you can argue with, once you work out it was handed to you. Guilt is about what you actually did to people who never asked for any of it, and that doesn't dissolve because you finally told the truth.

And building a body so you couldn't present as female. I went the other way and ate my way to three hundred pounds, which I'd always rounded down to 280 until I wrote it this week. Same instinct, opposite direction. Make the body impossible.

You're right that mine receded. I was convinced I was cured at thirty-five. It wasn't gone, it just went quiet and turned up again in the middle of the night. Yours never gave you even that much.

The guilt is the long one. x

June Northey's avatar

Great article as always - took me a few days to get to reading it (life is crazy) but I got there. Shame was a massive factor here. My family buried me in it as a kid - be ashamed you cried at a movie, be ashamed you play with girls, be ashamed you suck at sports, be ashamed you haven't had sex yet (only had it with my wife after we got married, and not since she died).

Being trans was the ultimate shame. June kept trying to come out, but I kept pushing her back - it wasn't time, it wasn't safe. 1986 (first time nearly out) zero support, family won't support you or if they do it'll be the 'we love our kid even though they are a mass murder' type of support. The late 90's I nearly did to friends but the fear/shame kept me from doing it. 2002 I came out to a councilor but was deep in debt so June was locked up again. 2014 my wife died and I desperately wanted to let June live but felt it would be too much on the kids. 2025 my parents died and I knew it was now or never - talked to a therapist but more told them. Found local supports and that was the last straw, June was out and never, ever, ever is going back in. John now is dead - just waiting on the paperwork to make it official (name change). The shame over it is down to near 0. I'm accepted virtually everywhere, even in places you'd never expect (at a church run second hand store the lady at the cash complimented my nails and we chatted about our kids for a bit - was nervous shopping there as I figured if anywhere was going to not be accepting that was it).

Stevie Bennett's avatar

January 28th. You know the exact date.

The week waiting to tell your daughters sounds worse than the telling. Already decided, and still having to carry it about with you. x

June Northey's avatar

Exact date and time - meeting started at 6, by 8 I knew my old self wasn't getting another shot, that June was about to start living her life at long last. My friend tells me it was an obvious shift, the scared man who came was dying, the vibrant woman left the building ready to live. That time (week and a half) before coming out was hell. Biting my lip, fighting to hold it in as it was critical to tell the kids all at once. The fact it went perfectly well was a miracle. The fact my reveal to the world went smoothly was too. I just wish yours had been positive as well. So sad when I see those who didn't have my good fortune.

Stevie Bennett's avatar

Two hours, and you can see it happen in the timings. The scared man who walked in, the woman who left.

And that’s kind, but don’t be sad on my account. The fortnight of biting your lip is the part I recognise. x

Stevie Bennett's avatar

Thank you. That one took a while to get down. x